Why look beyond BigCommerce
BigCommerce provides a robust e-commerce platform suitable for various business sizes, from small businesses requiring foundational selling tools to larger enterprises needing extensive customization and B2B capabilities. Its architecture supports both traditional storefronts and headless commerce implementations, offering flexibility for developers through its comprehensive API and SDKs for languages like Node.js, PHP, Python, and Ruby (BigCommerce Developer Documentation). Compliance with standards such as PCI DSS 4.0, SOC 2 Type II, GDPR, and CCPA addresses security and data privacy concerns.
However, businesses may consider alternatives based on specific needs. For instance, some users might seek platforms with a simpler entry point and lower initial costs, particularly for very small businesses or those with limited technical resources. Others might require deeper specialization in certain areas, such as highly custom storefront designs achievable with open-source solutions or niche integrations for specific industries. The total cost of ownership, including transaction fees and app ecosystem pricing, can also be a deciding factor, leading some to explore platforms with different pricing models or more extensive free app marketplaces.
Top alternatives ranked
-
1. Shopify — A hosted e-commerce platform for businesses of all sizes
Shopify is a prominent e-commerce platform that provides tools for creating online stores, managing products, processing orders, and handling payments. It is known for its user-friendly interface and extensive app store, which offers integrations for marketing, shipping, inventory management, and more. Shopify supports a wide range of businesses, from individuals and small startups to large enterprises, with different plans tailored to various needs (Shopify Official Website). The platform also offers a robust API and a theme development environment for developers to customize storefronts and expand functionality (Shopify Admin API Documentation). Shopify's ecosystem simplifies many aspects of online retail, including multi-channel sales, dropshipping, and point-of-sale (POS) systems for physical retail locations.
Best for:
- Small to medium-sized businesses seeking an intuitive, all-in-one solution.
- Merchants prioritizing ease of setup and a vast app ecosystem.
- Businesses requiring integrated POS solutions for retail.
-
2. Magento (Adobe Commerce) — An open-source, extensible platform for enterprise e-commerce
Magento, now known as Adobe Commerce, is an open-source e-commerce platform designed for scalability and extensive customization, primarily targeting medium to large enterprises (Adobe Commerce Official Overview). It offers powerful features for product management, marketing, and order processing, alongside capabilities for multi-store management and internationalization. Developers can leverage its modular architecture to build highly tailored e-commerce experiences and integrate with various business systems. Magento requires more technical expertise to set up and maintain compared to hosted solutions, often involving dedicated development and hosting. Its flexibility allows businesses to implement complex B2B functionalities, advanced merchandising, and bespoke customer experiences, making it a suitable choice for companies with specific, evolving requirements.
Best for:
- Large enterprises needing extensive customization and control over their e-commerce infrastructure.
- Businesses with in-house development teams or dedicated agency support.
- Companies requiring complex B2B functionalities and multi-store management.
-
3. WooCommerce — An open-source e-commerce plugin for WordPress
WooCommerce is a free, open-source e-commerce plugin for WordPress, enabling users to transform any WordPress website into a fully functional online store (WooCommerce Official Website). It provides core e-commerce features such as product catalogs, shopping carts, checkout processes, and order management. As it runs on WordPress, WooCommerce benefits from WordPress's extensive ecosystem of themes, plugins, and community support, offering significant flexibility in design and functionality. Users have full control over their site's hosting, data, and code, which can be advantageous for businesses seeking complete ownership and customization. While the core plugin is free, additional premium extensions, themes, and hosting costs contribute to the total investment. WooCommerce is well-suited for businesses that are already using or plan to use WordPress and desire a highly customizable e-commerce solution.
Best for:
- Small to medium-sized businesses already using WordPress.
- Users seeking complete control over their website and e-commerce store.
- Budget-conscious businesses willing to manage hosting and technical aspects themselves.
-
4. Stripe — A suite of payment processing APIs and tools
Stripe is a technology company that provides payment processing infrastructure for online businesses (Stripe Official Website). While not a full e-commerce platform like BigCommerce, Shopify, or Magento, Stripe offers APIs and tools that are essential components for any online store, enabling businesses to accept payments, manage subscriptions, and facilitate marketplace transactions (Stripe Documentation). Its developer-centric approach offers extensive customization and integration capabilities, allowing businesses to build custom checkout flows and integrate payment functionality directly into their applications. Stripe supports a wide range of payment methods, including credit cards, digital wallets, and local payment options, and provides tools for fraud prevention and financial reporting. Businesses often use Stripe in conjunction with other e-commerce platforms or custom-built solutions to handle the transactional aspects of their online sales.
Best for:
- Businesses needing flexible, developer-friendly payment processing.
- SaaS companies managing subscriptions and recurring billing.
- Marketplaces facilitating payments between multiple parties.
-
5. Shopify Admin API — Programmatic access to Shopify store data and operations
The Shopify Admin API provides programmatic access to store data and operations within the Shopify platform, allowing developers to build custom applications and integrations (Shopify Admin API Documentation). It enables tasks such as managing products, orders, customers, inventory, and discounts outside the standard Shopify admin interface. While technically part of the broader Shopify ecosystem, it serves as an alternative for businesses that need to extend or customize Shopify's core functionalities more deeply than theme modifications or standard app installations allow. This API supports headless commerce implementations, where the storefront is decoupled from the backend, providing maximum flexibility for front-end design using frameworks like React or Vue. It is utilized by businesses with specific operational workflows, complex data synchronization requirements, or unique customer experiences that cannot be achieved with off-the-shelf solutions.
Best for:
- Businesses implementing headless commerce with Shopify as the backend.
- Developers building custom applications and integrations for Shopify stores.
- Automating complex store operations and data synchronization.
Side-by-side
| Feature | BigCommerce | Shopify | Magento (Adobe Commerce) | WooCommerce | Stripe | Shopify Admin API |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform Type | Hosted E-commerce Platform | Hosted E-commerce Platform | Open-Source E-commerce Platform (Self-hosted or Cloud) | WordPress Plugin (Self-hosted) | Payment Processing API | API for Shopify Stores |
| Primary Use Case | Online stores (B2C, B2B, headless) | Online stores, POS, multi-channel sales | Enterprise e-commerce, complex B2B | E-commerce on WordPress websites | Payment acceptance, subscriptions | Custom Shopify integrations, headless commerce |
| Ease of Use (Setup) | Moderate | High | Low (requires technical expertise) | Moderate (requires WordPress knowledge) | Moderate (developer-centric) | Low (developer-centric) |
| Customization Level | High (API for headless, theme editor) | High (API, theme editor, apps) | Very High (open-source code access) | Very High (open-source code access, WordPress ecosystem) | High (custom UI, flexible integrations) | Very High (direct API control) |
| Pricing Model | Subscription + sales tiers | Subscription + transaction fees (optional) | Enterprise license (custom), self-hosting costs | Free plugin, paid extensions, hosting costs | Per-transaction fees | Included with Shopify subscription |
| Developer Focus | Strong (API, SDKs: Node.js, PHP, Python, Ruby) | Strong (API, SDKs: Ruby, Python, PHP, Node.js, GraphQL) | Very Strong (PHP, extensive community) | Strong (PHP, WordPress action/filter hooks) | Very Strong (APIs, SDKs: Node, Python, Ruby, PHP, Java, Go, .NET) | Very Strong (API, SDKs: Ruby, Python, PHP, Node.js, GraphQL) |
| Best for Small Businesses | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes (for payment processing) | No (requires development) |
| Best for Enterprises | Yes | Yes (Shopify Plus) | Yes | No (typically not for very large) | Yes | Yes |
| Headless Commerce Support | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | N/A (payment component) | Yes |
| PCI DSS Compliance | Yes | Yes | Requires self-certification for self-hosted | Requires self-certification for self-hosted | Yes | Inherits from Shopify |
How to pick
Selecting an e-commerce platform requires evaluating your business's specific needs, technical capabilities, and long-term growth objectives. Consider these factors when choosing between BigCommerce and its alternatives:
- Business Size and Scalability:
- For small businesses or startups prioritizing quick setup and ease of use, Shopify offers an intuitive interface and a comprehensive app store. BigCommerce also caters to this segment but might have a slightly steeper learning curve for some functionalities.
- For medium to large businesses with significant growth plans, both BigCommerce and Shopify (especially Shopify Plus) provide scalable solutions. Magento (Adobe Commerce) is a strong contender for enterprises requiring deep customization, complex B2B features, and extensive integrations, though it demands substantial technical resources.
- Technical Expertise and Control:
- If you have limited technical knowledge or prefer a fully managed solution, hosted platforms like BigCommerce and Shopify reduce the operational burden of server maintenance and security.
- If you have an in-house development team or prefer complete control over your code and hosting environment, open-source solutions like Magento or WooCommerce (built on WordPress) offer maximum flexibility. However, this comes with the responsibility of managing infrastructure, security, and updates.
- For developers building highly customized applications or headless commerce frontends, the BigCommerce API, Shopify Admin API, and custom integrations with payment solutions like Stripe provide the necessary tools.
- Budget and Cost Structure:
- Hosted platforms typically involve monthly subscription fees that vary by features and sales volume. Be aware of transaction fees, app costs, and themes, which can add to the total cost of ownership.
- Open-source solutions (Magento, WooCommerce) have no direct platform licensing fees for their core versions but incur costs for hosting, development, premium extensions, and ongoing maintenance. Ensure you factor in all these variables.
- Payment gateways like Stripe operate on a per-transaction fee model, which can be a key cost component for any e-commerce operation.
- Specific Feature Requirements:
- If B2B commerce features (e.g., customer groups, bulk pricing, quotes) are critical, BigCommerce and Magento provide strong native support.
- For multi-channel selling, including social media, marketplaces, and physical retail, Shopify offers robust integrations and a comprehensive POS system. BigCommerce also supports multi-channel strategies.
- For specific regional payment methods or complex subscription billing, a dedicated payment provider like Stripe offers extensive capabilities and developer-friendly APIs.